Weezer

* NOTE: You can still visit the old Message Board for a limited time here > http://makebelieve.weezer.com/community/

---The Red Album (US Deluxe) Elimination Thread---

Community / All Things Weezer / ---The Red Album (US Deluxe) Elimination Thread---
6/11/2008 9:16 AM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

---The Red Album (US Deluxe) Elimination Thread---

Lives Song Title
_____ _____________________
XXXXX Troublemaker
XXXXX The Greatest Man That Ever Lived
XXXXX Pork and Beans
XXXXX Heart Songs
XXXXX Everybody Get Dangerous
XXXXX Dreamin'
XXXXX Thought I Knew
XXXXX Cold Dark World
XXXXX Automatic
XXXXX The Angel And The One
XXXXX Miss Sweeney
XXXXX Pig
XXXXX The Spider
XXXXX King


You have prolly seen one of these threads before; however, I have yet to see one on the Weezer boards for the Red Album. Here are the rules for this Elimination match.

#1. Only 1 Vote per poster per day

#2. You take 1 X away from your least favorite song left with any lives

#3. You put 1 X onto your favorite song left with at least 1 life.

#4. You keep the format of the thread the same in all replies

I will start with my reply... I hope everyone enjoys. As eliminations happen, I will post rankings of 1st eliminated to winner.


-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

First «Prev 6 7 8 9 10 Next» Last (401 to 450 of 587)
7/21/2008 2:55 PM (GMT-08:00)
crystal_iceburg

Re: i too have balls

TGMTEL - 38
Pork and Beans - 5
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 14

tgmtel-
pork+

out of these songs p+b is the best to sing along to, imo


-------
i write these stupid words, and i love everyone waiting there for me, yes i do.... yes i do.

Quote Report 

7/21/2008 3:57 PM (GMT-08:00)
rezeewkram

Re: Angel's can't die. They're angels

TGMTEL - 38
Pork and Beans - 4
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 15


-1 pork and beans
+1 angel

Quote Report 

7/21/2008 8:46 PM (GMT-08:00)
Emptysea

Re: I'm a bit of a copy cat, I suppose...

TGMTEL - 38
Pork and Beans - 3
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 14


I, much like Mr. rezeewram, will be adding a vote to The Angel and the One.
And I will once again remove a number from Pork and Beans.

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 7:20 AM (GMT-08:00)
weezer juggler

Re: +,-

TGMTEL - 38
Pork and Beans - 2
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 15


The usual


-------
Dayman, fighter of The Nightman. Champion of the sun. You're a master of karate and friendship for everyone

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 10:40 AM (GMT-08:00)
Only_in_Weezer

Re: .

TGMTEL - 38
Pork and Beans - 1
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 15

You know the drill with me by know.
+Angel
-Pork

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 1:47 PM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: ./,

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 16

-1 BEAN w/ PORK
+1 ANGEL AND THE ONE, which is better than Dreamin in every fucking way


-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 1:49 PM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: Ranking Update


Ranks:
14th: Cold Dark World (June 11th, lasted 7 hours)
13th: The Spider (June 12th, lasted 1 day)
12th: Everybody Get Dangerous (June 13th, lasted 2 days)
11th: Heart Songs (June 14th, lasted 3 days)
10th: Thought I Knew (June 14th, lasted 3 days)
9th: Automatic (June 20th, lasted 9 days)
8th: King (June 25th, lasted 14 days)
7th: Miss Sweeney (June 28, lasted 17 days)
6th: Pig (July 1, lasted 20 days)
5th: Troublemaker (July 9, lasted 28)
4th: Pork and Beans (July 22, lasted 41)


-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 1:53 PM (GMT-08:00)
No.1 RC_Fan

Re: Wow, Elimination

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 14
The Angel and the One - 15

+1 Three Men
-1 TAATO


-------
\^/ |-', |-', ''/_ |-', |-\

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 4:29 PM (GMT-08:00)
ionic sky

Re: angel even with dreamin

TGMTEL - 37
Dreamin' - 15
The Angel and the One - 15

+1 Dreamin
-1 TGMTEL

all three songs are good, i just don't think TGMTEL is THAT much better than the other two.


-------
Who will save your soul if you won't save your own? -Jewel

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 4:32 PM (GMT-08:00)
Only_in_Weezer

Re: Re: .

quote icon Only_in_Weezer wrote:

TGMTEL - 38
Pork and Beans - 1
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 15

You know the drill with me by know.
+Angel
-Pork


Argh! Why can't I edit my post now. It's so annoying to see that incorrect grammar.

Sorry to go OT.

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 4:49 PM (GMT-08:00)
No.1 RC_Fan

Re: .

quote icon Only_in_Weezer wrote:

OT


?

-------
\^/ |-', |-', ''/_ |-', |-\

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 4:54 PM (GMT-08:00)
Only_in_Weezer

Re: Re: .

quote icon No.1 RC_Fan wrote:

quote icon Only_in_Weezer wrote:

OT


?


Off Topic.

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 5:47 PM (GMT-08:00)
MakeUpOnShelf86

Re: ...

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 14
The Angel and the One - 15

+1 TGMTEL
-1 Dreamin'

Amazing Dreamin' lasted this long. Not disappointed, just surprised.

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 5:56 PM (GMT-08:00)
No.1 RC_Fan

Re: Re: Re: .

quote icon Only_in_Weezer wrote:

quote icon No.1 RC_Fan wrote:

quote icon Only_in_Weezer wrote:

OT


?


Off Topic.


Ah.

-------
\^/ |-', |-', ''/_ |-', |-\

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 6:38 PM (GMT-08:00)
weezer juggler

Re: +,-

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 16


-1 Dreamin', +1 The Angel and the One


-------
Dayman, fighter of The Nightman. Champion of the sun. You're a master of karate and friendship for everyone

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 7:39 PM (GMT-08:00)
No.1 RC_Fan

Re: .

This whole thing reminds me of Random Elimination League. Except it's not random. And it's not a league. And it's real.


-------
\^/ |-', |-', ''/_ |-', |-\

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 9:33 PM (GMT-08:00)
moose.seagull

Re: yay! top 3!

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 14
The Angel and the One - 15

i remember when dreamin' was down to like 4. those of you who voted against it, what now?!

btw...anyone else just realize that we are missing 3 points? i vote we award all 3 an extra point to compensate.

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 9:46 PM (GMT-08:00)
No.1 RC_Fan

Re: I'm nothing if not honest... >_<

I checked on the missing 3, thanks for bringing it to attention.

UNFORTUNATELY...all three points belong on TAATO, lol.

Emptysea said he was taking one away from Pork and Beans and adding one to TAATO, but he took noe away from each. So, since he meant to add one to Angel, that means Angel needs 2 extra points after having one mistakenly removed.

Then Only in Weezer subtracted from one song, but forgot to add any, though he said he was adding one to TAATO. So that's another for Angel.

If anyone wants to see for himself, the two mistakes are both on this page.

Actual Standings:
TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 14
The Angel and the One - 18

Remember guys, 1 + 1 = 2.

[jk]


-------
\^/ |-', |-', ''/_ |-', |-\

Quote Report 

7/22/2008 10:28 PM (GMT-08:00)
Only_in_Weezer

Re: Re: I'm nothing if not honest... >_<

quote icon No.1 RC_Fan wrote:

I checked on the missing 3, thanks for bringing it to attention.

UNFORTUNATELY...all three points belong on TAATO, lol.

Emptysea said he was taking one away from Pork and Beans and adding one to TAATO, but he took noe away from each. So, since he meant to add one to Angel, that means Angel needs 2 extra points after having one mistakenly removed.

Then Only in Weezer subtracted from one song, but forgot to add any, though he said he was adding one to TAATO. So that's another for Angel.

If anyone wants to see for himself, the two mistakes are both on this page.

Actual Standings:
TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 14
The Angel and the One - 18

Remember guys, 1 + 1 = 2.

[jk]


I appreciate you two catching my mistake. Sorry about that and thanks for your honesty.

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 10:25 AM (GMT-08:00)
moose.seagull

Re: x_x

i wish i had never said anything.

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 15
The Angel and the One - 17




Quote Report 

7/23/2008 10:43 AM (GMT-08:00)
weezeroscillatingfan

Re: No sweeney???

This is the first time I've looked at this thread... but you eliminated Mrs. Sweeney? what is wrong with you people?

XXXXXX Troublemaker
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX The Greatest Man That Ever Lived
XXXXXX Pork and Beans
XXXXXXXXXX Dreamin'
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX The Angel and the One

plus troublemaker, minus pork n beans


-------
Crab at the booty, taint gonna do no good

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 10:48 AM (GMT-08:00)
weezeroscillatingfan

Re: woops...

sorry, I thought page 5 was the last one, my bad. Just disregard my votes.


-------
Crab at the booty, taint gonna do no good

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 10:54 AM (GMT-08:00)
Wold91

Re: Re: x_x

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 16
The Angel and the One - 16

+ Dreamin'
- TAATO




-------
The Red Album rocks! And Pinkerton is classic!

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 11:28 AM (GMT-08:00)
crystal_iceburg

Re: i'm dreeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaamin' in the morning....

TGMTEL - 37
Dreamin' - 17
The Angel and the One - 16


dreamin' +
tgmtel -


-------
i write these stupid words, and i love everyone waiting there for me, yes i do.... yes i do.

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 2:55 PM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: hello

TGMTEL - 37
Dreamin' - 16
The Angel and the One - 17

+a1 sauce
-onlyindreamsexceptbad


PS, hey my avatar got approved finally! Who wants to make out?


-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 6:41 PM (GMT-08:00)
ionic sky

Re: ...

TGMTEL - 36
Dreamin' - 17
The Angel and the One - 17


+ Dreamin
- TGMTEL


-------
Who will save your soul if you won't save your own? -Jewel

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 7:13 PM (GMT-08:00)
MakeUpOnShelf86

Re: ,,,

TGMTEL - 36
Dreamin' - 16
The Angel and the One - 18

+1 TAATO
-1 Dreamin'

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 8:33 PM (GMT-08:00)
LongtimeSunshine

Re: another vote, 7/23 at 11:35 PM EST

TGMTEL - 37
Dreamin' - 15
The Angel and the One - 18

+1 for TGMTEL
-1 for Dreamin'

It's funny. These songs are three of my four favorites on the album. I see that I have similar taste to most Weezer fans. They're classic songs, and solidify The Red Album as the band's best work since The Green or, possibly, Pinkerton. I think Angel and the One is better than Only in Dreams.

BUT I'm disappointed Heart Songs went out so early! Not my favorite the first few times I listened to the album, but now it's in my Top 2 with TGMTEL. The bridge is especially wonderful. :)


-------
Across The Sea. Say It Ain't So. Teenage Victory Song. Pink Triangle. In The Garage. ...these are my heart songs.

Quote Report 

7/23/2008 10:51 PM (GMT-08:00)
Only_in_Weezer

Re: .

TGMTEL - 36
Dreamin' - 15
The Angel and the One - 19

+1 TAatO
-1 TGMTEL

Whenever I vote against TGMTEL I feel like I'm dissing Rivers. Sorry big guy.

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 1:30 AM (GMT-08:00)
ghostghostghost

Re: yeah

CANNOT believe you voted out pig, ms sweeney and pork and beans.


TGMTEL - 36
Dreamin' - 14
The Angel and the One - 20


TAATO +1
dreamin' -1


-------
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 7:10 AM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: Re: yeah

quote icon ghostghostghost wrote:

CANNOT believe you voted out pig, ms sweeney and pork and beans.


Dude this is your first vote, you can't complain if you don't vote.

-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 7:13 AM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: Re: another vote, 7/23 at 11:35 PM EST

quote icon LongtimeSunshine wrote:

I think Angel and the One is better than Only in Dreams.

BUT I'm disappointed Heart Songs went out so early! Not my favorite the first few times I listened to the album, but now it's in my Top 2 with TGMTEL. The bridge is especially wonderful. :)


I hate you to the 10th degree. If you ever say Heart Songs is better than all but TGMTEL again I will hunt you down. You are my enemy. Furthermore, you then proceeded to shit on the face of Only in Dreams. You my friend are the devil... no you are lower than the devil.... you my anti-friend.... are.... Nickleback.... or dare I say, Puddle of Mud. Good riddens to you, and may god have mercy on your soul.

-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 7:14 AM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: ./, i am the bomber

TGMTEL - 36
Dreamin' - 13
The Angel and the One - 21

+a1
-dream


-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 7:41 AM (GMT-08:00)
weezer juggler

Re: +,-

TGMTEL - 36
Dreamin' - 12
The Angel and the One - 22


-1 Dreamin', +1 The Angel and the One


-------
Dayman, fighter of The Nightman. Champion of the sun. You're a master of karate and friendship for everyone

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 9:01 AM (GMT-08:00)
MakeUpOnShelf86

Re: ...

TGMTEL - 37
Dreamin' - 11
The Angel and the One - 22

+1 TGMTEL
-1 Dreamin'

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 9:57 AM (GMT-08:00)
crystal_iceburg

Re: this is too hard

TGMTEL - 38
Dreamin' - 11
The Angel and the One - 21

tgmtel +
taato -


-------
i write these stupid words, and i love everyone waiting there for me, yes i do.... yes i do.

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 10:37 AM (GMT-08:00)
G_Foo_Chombey

Re: BLAH

+ TGMTEL
-Dreamin'


so...
TGMTEL - 39
Dreamin' - 10
The Angel and the One - 21


-------
"Let's put a revolt!"

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 11:26 AM (GMT-08:00)
Wold91

Re: I will fight for DREAMIN'!!

TGMTEL - 39
Dreamin' - 11
The Angel and the One - 20

+ Dreamin'
- TAATO


-------
The Red Album rocks! And Pinkerton is classic!

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 3:21 PM (GMT-08:00)
LongtimeSunshine

Re: Replying to cheesy smile dude...

quote icon Encenoa wrote:

quote icon LongtimeSunshine wrote:

I think Angel and the One is better than Only in Dreams.

BUT I'm disappointed Heart Songs went out so early! Not my favorite the first few times I listened to the album, but now it's in my Top 2 with TGMTEL. The bridge is especially wonderful. :)


I hate you to the 10th degree. If you ever say Heart Songs is better than all but TGMTEL again I will hunt you down. You are my enemy. Furthermore, you then proceeded to shit on the face of Only in Dreams. You my friend are the devil... no you are lower than the devil.... you my anti-friend.... are.... Nickleback.... or dare I say, Puddle of Mud. Good riddens to you, and may god have mercy on your soul.



Whoa dude, I was like *this* close to reporting you. How dare you compare me to Nickelback or Puddle of Mudd? That is a completely undeserved disgrace. Listen to Heart Songs more - it's personal, fun, catchy, rockin', and Rivers' voice sounds amazing. That bridge is CRAZY HOT. And I didn't say it was the second best on the album, but at the moment it's my second favorite to listen to. It's much better than most of the album.

Also, Only in Dreams is still overrated in my book. Rivers himself has called it "gay" (being homophobic), "boring," embarassing, and poorly written. Haven't you read the book, Rivers' Edge? So if you think I just shit on your favorite Rivers song, then you ought to yell at the writer himself.

-------
Across The Sea. Say It Ain't So. Teenage Victory Song. Pink Triangle. In The Garage. ...these are my heart songs.

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 3:22 PM (GMT-08:00)
LongtimeSunshine

Re: another vote

TGMTEL - 40
Dreamin' - 10
The Angel and the One - 20

- Dreamin'
+ TGMTEL


-------
Across The Sea. Say It Ain't So. Teenage Victory Song. Pink Triangle. In The Garage. ...these are my heart songs.

Quote Report 

7/24/2008 6:21 PM (GMT-08:00)
ionic sky

Re: ...

TGMTEL - 40
Dreamin' - 11
The Angel and the One - 19

+ Dreamin'
- TAATO


-------
Who will save your soul if you won't save your own? -Jewel

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 8:28 AM (GMT-08:00)
Encenoa

Re: ./,

TGMTEL - 41
Dreamin' - 10
The Angel and the One - 19

-dream
+greatman

decided to change it up


-------
all the girls get up when I sing, yah

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 8:36 AM (GMT-08:00)
MakeUpOnShelf86

Re: ...

TGMTEL - 41
Dreamin' - 9
The Angel and the One - 20

+1 TAATO
-1 Dreamin'

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 12:09 PM (GMT-08:00)
a51disaster

Re: WTF!?!?!?!?

TGMTEL - 41
Dreamin' - 10
The Angel and the One - 19

-1 TAATO
+1 Dreamin'

I leave for a week and PnB is the song to not make the top 3!?!? wtf happened to TAATO's nose dive...dammit...what happened to the Dreamin' haters too? I'm so lost and confused...

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 1:28 PM (GMT-08:00)
surfwaxasia

Re: alright.

TGMTEL - 41
Dreamin - 9
TAATO - 20

-1 Dreamin
+1 TAATO


-------
March 23, Hush the win, the music died.

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 2:00 PM (GMT-08:00)
LongtimeSunshine

Re: hi

TGMTEL - 42
Dreamin - 8
TAATO - 20

-1 Dreamin
+1 TAATO


-------
Across The Sea. Say It Ain't So. Teenage Victory Song. Pink Triangle. In The Garage. ...these are my heart songs.

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 2:17 PM (GMT-08:00)
moose.seagull

Re: i'm gone for 2 days and the haters take over?! wtf is going on?!

TGMTEL - 42
Dreamin' - 9
TAATO - 19

you all suck.

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 2:33 PM (GMT-08:00)
ionic sky

Re: it's just that TGMTEL has SOO many votes.

TGMTEL - 41
Dreamin' - 10
TAATO - 19

+ Dreamin' , - TGMTEL


-------
Who will save your soul if you won't save your own? -Jewel

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 11:09 PM (GMT-08:00)
weezer juggler

Re: +,-

TGMTEL - 41
Dreamin' - 9
TAATO - 20


-1 Dreamin', +1 The Angel and the One


-------
Dayman, fighter of The Nightman. Champion of the sun. You're a master of karate and friendship for everyone

Quote Report 

7/25/2008 11:49 PM (GMT-08:00)
Only_in_Weezer

Re: .

TGMTEL - 40
Dreamin' - 9
TAATO - 21

+TAATO
-TGMTEL

Quote Report 

First «Prev 6 7 8 9 10 Next» Last (401 to 450 of 587)
Post Reply